Rick Vaz, Worcester Polytechnic Institute – Women in STEM Fields
On Worcester Polytechnic Institute Week: Keeping more women in STEM programs is a key focus for the future.
Rick Vaz, professor of interdisciplinary and global studies, explores one way to do it.
As Director of WPI’s Center for Project-Based Learning, I work with colleagues across campus to help advance project-based learning at colleges and universities around the nation and the globe. We also support project-based learning here on the WPI campus. Most of my scholarly and professional activity centers around experiential and international education. Through my involvement in organizations such as the Association of American Colleges and Universities and the American Society for Engineering Education, I work to promote WPI’s approach to undergraduate education as a national model.
I received my PhD in electrical engineering from WPI, focusing on signal analysis and machine vision. I held systems and design engineering positions with the Raytheon Company, GenRad Inc., and the MITRE Corporation before joining the WPI Electrical and Computer Engineering faculty in 1987. While I greatly enjoyed my work as an engineering faculty member, over time my interests in interdisciplinary teaching and learning and international education resulted in increasing involvement in WPI’s student project programs, both on campus and elsewhere. I served as Dean of Interdisciplinary and Global Studies for ten years, and have advised hundreds of undergraduate research projects in Australia, England, Greece, Hong Kong, Ireland, Italy, Namibia, the Netherlands, Thailand, and the United States.
Women in STEM Fields
Despite years of effort, attracting and retaining more women into STEM fields remains an elusive challenge. Research suggests women are more motivated than men by work that helps others, and by collaborative work. While science and technology can transform lives and are increasingly collaborative, too often they are viewed as solitary pursuits more focused on things than on people.
A recent study sheds light on how pedagogy could address these challenges. The study looked at over 2500 STEM graduates from a project-based curriculum ranging over 38 graduating classes. Alumni were asked about long-term impacts of undergraduate project work. While most alumni reported a wide range of benefits, women reported more positive impacts from a project-based education than men in 36 of 39 areas.
Some differences were in professional impacts. Women were significantly more likely than men to report that project work helped them “much” or “very much” in problem solving, communication, and professional interactions.
Differences in personal impacts were equally striking, with women reporting benefits in character development and self-efficacy at significantly higher rates than men.
In interviews, alumnae described how real-world applications involved in project work helped them see how technical careers could connect with their interests. One said “these projects really allowed me to see the impacts on society that engineering can have…, and it really stimulated my interest in staying with engineering.”
While the study reveals a wide range of professional and personal benefits to both men and women, these differences suggest that project-based learning could be a powerful strategy to attract and retain more talented women into science and technology fields.
Those were some very good comments on attracting and retaining women in STEM using project-based training. I am a mathematician, but I am one who always loved both both its abstract and applicable beauty. We are a family of mathematicians. My husband was a physics major and a math minor; two daughters have mathematics degrees; and one daughter is a certified cryptological engineer and a cybersecurity expert. So we “bleed” STEM. I agree that the project-based paradigm can draw them to it, but you still have to love the stuff to make you enjoy the stay.
Some very great points here. I will share this with colleagues. We always try to get the women into the y door but do a poor job keeping them in. Now we can take some of these ideas on board.
When I took STEM courses the ones I learned to most in were ones with meaningful projects, Busy work projects are not valuable.
I use PBL for my honors sessions. The students enjoy it, they learn a lot. I learn a lot by working with them, discussing ideas and questions that they come up with and connect that with the material we study in class.
Great points.Like it
Interesting article. It sounds like project-based learning is definitely the way to go in the future.
Interesting and valuable information!
I especially value project based learning that embraces more comprehensive projects, such as a culminating experience at the end of the year. I often find that students learn A in Sept and B in Oct and C in Nov and D in Dec… and by April, they don’t remember diddley-squat about A or B. Use it or lose it, as they say. So I believe that end of year projects that aren’t about NEW learning but rather are about RETAINING learning are just as valuable.
Project-based learning and collaborative work should be a focus of STEM research and education
Interesting. My daughter is a recent graduate of ISU with a major in Biology. She is heading for graduate school so she will not be “stuck in a lab” all day, but instead get to deal with people. Hmmmm…
Project-based learning aims at intellectual and emotional development and helps retain students in STEM and other programs.
It would be useful to highlight more role models and their work and contributions.